Loading...
We use cookies for analytics and (eventually) advertising to keep TheFantasyPicks free. See our Privacy Policy.
Sponsored affiliate link.
Player photos courtesy of ESPN.
Ranking moves, risers and fallers, and new posts. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
All 32 teams played once, all 16 games are final, and most of what happened does not matter. Preseason box scores never do. What matters is the small number of real, concrete things that came out of this weekend: a QB competition that just got a data point, a rookie who separated himself, an injury that changes a depth chart. Here is the Week 1 signal, organized by theme instead of by score, with a link to the full recap of every game if you want the details.
Six different QB rooms got real information this weekend, and none of them resolved cleanly.
Indianapolis split its opener between Anthony Richardson and rookie Riley Leonard, with Leonard now confirmed to start Week 2. Deshaun Watson, Cleveland's starter, got his first live action since 2024 before Shedeur Sanders took over for a promising-then-costly relief stint, while Caleb Williams, Chicago's quarterback, sat on the bench entirely and still watched his team blow out Cleveland behind a career game from a third-string arm. Green Bay's real fight is for QB3, where Kyle McCord outplayed undrafted rookie Kyron Drones across the board. The Jets got a real scare when Geno Smith was scratched with a sore ankle and rookie Cade Klubnik made the most of a surprise start, leading Tampa Bay 10-0 before he came out.
Fernando Mendoza Justin Fields Kyler Murray Cam WardThe rookie class made its first real impression too. Fernando Mendoza's Raiders debut behind Kirk Cousins was clean, but the most efficient rookie arm of the weekend belonged to the Rams: Ty Simpson went 21 of 25 for 190 yards and two touchdowns backing up Matthew Stafford, the best statistical line any quarterback put up in Week 1. On the other sideline, Justin Fields went 4 for 4 in relief of Patrick Mahomes, who was on the field only for the coin toss while still working back from his ACL/LCL surgery, a reminder that Kansas City's timeline for its actual starter is still the only thing that matters there. Minnesota's Kyler Murray got the start over J.J. McCarthy exactly as the depth chart said he would, and Cam Ward's rough night for Tennessee (5 of 12, 57 yards, a fumble) was the one clean box score you should not overreact to this early.
A handful of skill players did something that should actually change how you rank them.
Jeremiyah Love, the third overall pick, ran for 58 yards on 11 carries in his Cardinals debut despite starting behind Tyler Allgeier with James Conner still recovering from foot surgery. Cleveland's KC Concepcion scored on an end-around in his first game action, while fellow Browns rookie Denzel Boston is already crowding Jerry Jeudy for reps. Ja'Kobi Lane, part of Baltimore's rookie class, caught a 16-yard touchdown in an otherwise sleepy Eagles-Ravens game, and San Francisco's De'Zhaun Stribling, an undrafted rookie, quietly outplayed Carnell Tate, Tennessee's No. 4 overall pick. Tate finished with zero catches on three targets while still working behind Wan'Dale Robinson and Elic Ayomanor on his own team's depth chart.
The undrafted class had a weekend too. Myles Price's one-handed touchdown reopened Minnesota's WR4 race after he entered camp buried on the depth chart, and Tampa Bay got a real look at two of its own priority undrafted signings, quarterback Jalon Daniels and cornerback Ayden Garnes, who returned a pick-six 47 yards in the same game Klubnik started.
The single cleanest through-line of the weekend connects two different games. Seattle traded Kenneth Walker III to Kansas City this offseason, and rookie Jadarian Price, the No. 32 overall pick brought in specifically to replace him, got his first look in the Seahawks backfield in a 17-7 loss to Dallas. On the other side of that trade, Walker is now buried on a crowded Kansas City depth chart behind a Chiefs offense that spent the day protecting Mahomes' recovery timeline instead of feeding anyone.
Elsewhere, actual roles shifted. Denver rookie Jonah Coleman looked efficient in a real four-touch sample in a crowded Broncos backfield, Buffalo debuted newly-acquired DJ Moore after the Bills traded a second-round pick to Chicago to get him, and Carolina got a real, if brief, look at Jonathon Brooks in his first extended action since a second ACL tear.
Most preseason injuries are noise. A few from this weekend are not. Chase Bisontis, Arizona's second-round guard, is done for the year with a torn MCL. Jamal Adams left on a non-contact right knee injury and was carted off the field, with Minnesota saying the initial exam "does not look good." Marcus Mariota, Washington's backup quarterback, suffered a sprained MCL in a game the team otherwise used to rest every real starter, and Houston is dealing with a suspected ACL re-tear for a depth quarterback that pushed Davis Mills into relief duty early. Jordyn Tyson, the Saints' rookie receiver, missed the Jaguars game entirely with a hamstring injury suffered in a joint practice, worth tracking before New Orleans' next exhibition.
None of this should move your actual draft board yet. Two more preseason weeks remain, and one efficient debut or one bad half is not a full sample. But camp battles are exactly what our best ball rankings and rookie rankings are built to track as they update, and if a name above is unranked or mispriced right now, that gap will not last. Run any of these situations through the mock draft simulator to see how much a real depth-chart change actually shifts a player's range of outcomes before you pay up for it. Preseason Week 2 runs August 20 through 23, and that is when this list gets a real second data point.
Full recaps for every Week 1 game: Lions-Bengals, Packers-Steelers, Colts-Patriots, Chargers-Texans, Cardinals-Raiders, Titans-49ers, Broncos-Falcons, Buccaneers-Jets, Dolphins-Commanders, Panthers-Bills, Browns-Bears, Vikings-Giants, Rams-Chiefs, Jaguars-Saints, Eagles-Ravens, and Cowboys-Seahawks.
